27.7.11

Why the Mumbai Attacks shouldn’t have surprised anyone

The story of why this attack was allowed to happen.



The latest Mumbai tragedy is the fourteenth terrorist attack on the city since 1993, raising the total terrorism-related death toll in the city to 701. With history repeating itself yet again, one has to wonder how many more attacks the so-called “spirit of Mumbai,” if there ever was one, can bear before it breaks. Of course, the most tragic aspect of the attack remains that it came as no surprise, at least to those who were observing the situation closely.

While no one could have predicted where exactly the attack would be and on what date, given the developments of the last two years gave a clear indication that a major attack is coming somewhere in the middle of 2011. In fact, we provided this risk assessment regularly to public and the government, to be ignored regularly. Worse yet, if this attack receives the same apathetic response that was given to the previous indicators, we can expect more and bigger attacks on other major cities by the year’s end . 

The meaningless ritual of Terrorism




We as South Asian people have a thing for rituals. Be it religion or society or governance, we have an uncanny ability to distill a legitimate process into a rite devoid of any semblance of meaning or purpose that we continue to faithfully follow eternally without ever questioning its efficacy. Bollywood churns out movies based on the same formula, government follows the same archaic rules written a century ago and housewives, across the country, wake up every day at four in the morning to water their Tulsi plants, the sole symbol of vegetation in their household. 

Now, it seems, terrorism has also become a meaningless ritual, a theatrical performance where everyone faithfully acts out his or her role, disregarding any possibility that the whole exercise may be pointless. 
In this theatre, we all know our roles. The terrorists need to kill random people in a random city. The government needs to be unapologetically apathetic. Media needs to be outraged and jingoistic. Politicians need to resign, safe in the knowledge that they would be absorbed back into the government soon enough. Civil society needs to celebrate the artificial notion of the “Mumbai spirit”. Hotels and multiplexes need to start half-heartedly body searching their patrons again. As for the people, unfortunately, their role is simply to die.
As for the usefulness of this theatre, if there is any, it was lost long ago in the ashes of few first bombs that killed innocents in India. What does anyone gain out of all this? 

12.1.11

No Naxals will be hurt in the making of Telengana state


Finally! I have finished reading the 505-page Srikrishna Committee Report on Telengana issue (pdf). Above all, I realized two things- Justice Srikrishna is no John Grisham and I hate Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA). After wading through hundreds of pages documenting the ethno-religious and social details of the region I find out that the juicy part, internal security considerations, has been censored out, courtesy MHA. What am I supposed to read if not the Naxal angle?

Surprisingly, despite hardly mentioning Naxalism in its report (minus the censored security considerations) the committee report scares the bejesus out of anyone thinking that Naxalism wouldn’t be an issue in the state formation. And it is not the only one. Security agencies (read MHA) have already suggested to the government that creating Telengana will help Naxalism rise again. So the question is, whether Naxalism is a threat for Telengana or merely a bureaucratic excuse for the government to do their favorite thing in the whole world – maintain status quo.


5.1.11

#8 India congratulates itself on the 2010 Commonwealth Games Disaster



Following on the Chinese Olympian footsteps, India was all set to have its coming out party through New Delhi 2010 Commonwealth Games. World was watching a fledgling economy flex its muscle and enter the world stage. And then reality happened. Despite being the most expensive Commonwealth games ever (with a price tag if US$ 13 billion,) the games had everything going wrong. Corruption was rampant (a $2 toilet roll was bought for $80), child labor was repeatedly highlighted by CNN and construction schedule was late by more than a year. A dozen notable athletes refused to participate and 19,000-seater stadiums sometimes had less than 100 audience. Curling in Vancouver Winter Olympics got more audience than that. 

Is this women's beach volleyball?
No wonder Wikipedia page on Concerns and controversies over the 2010 Commonwealth Games is more than 10,000 words long. That’s three times the page on Second Sudanese Civil War.

Yet it did not stop Indian Government from claiming the event a success. Country’s media towed the line, hailing the overall event a victory and promptly forgetting about the whole debacle. 

Although this was nothing compared to the drama that unfolded in Fiji…

28.10.10

Why not to go the Chinese way on the Arundhati Roy issue















The recent statements by Syed Ali Shah Geelani, leader of separatist Kashmiri group Hurriyat and author Arundhati Roy about Kashmiri independence have raised a political storm in New Delhi. Several political parties and members of media have called out for arrests of these leaders on the charges of treason. Consequently there continues a constitutional debate in the country for the legality of their arrests.

Although the Delhi Police has been given a go-ahead to file charges against the leaders, it remains to be seen whether the arrests will actually be carried out. The government continues to refuse from committing itself to either side. While there is strong sentiments in New Delhi to appease, arrest of Geelani may lead to revived political protests in Kashmir and arrest of Roy may invite international criticism.

An interesting parallel is the recent drama that went on in China about Liu Xiabo who is the Nobel Peace Prize winner this year and currently under house-arrest in China. Immediately after the announcement of the prize, the Chinese led a major crackdown on internet erasing the news, arranged for a political hit-job on his character and rebuked Nobel prize committee for daring to give him the prize.

These are the reasons why we should not adopt the same model here at home:

1. International criticism not cool for a country trying to spit polish its Democracy medallions in a region full of dictatorships and communism.
2. Something called free speech as a constitutional right.
3. The fact that such statements from time-to-time are important to be made. Our government, like any other government, is not very effective in taking initiatives. It is only by forcing the government, by making big hue and cry that you can force any government to bring in reforms and I hope no one will disagree that we need reforms in Kashmir. I do not agree with Roy but I disagree with her arrest as well.

Someone just pointed out that I should be last person to cry free speech since I am in everyone's face who doesn't agree with me. But I do it for free, as an individual. The government is also free to do so, by bashing Roy through public statements. But arresting her would be crossing a line that I am really hoping we would not.

Again, I am saying Roy is an idiot who made an incorrect statement and she probably has no idea about the real situation in Kashmir. But that doesn't mean you should arrest her.

Image: Arundhati Roy, Liu Xiabo
Image credit: Jeanbaptisteparis, Voice of America

30.9.10

Thank you Ayadhya, CWG. I can finally breathe!

After a whole month of being stuck in traffic jams, waiting for hours for tables at restaurants and getting crushed in giant man-breasts of fellow passengers of the overcrowded Metro (I am Jack's claustrophobia) I can finally breathe! 

For the last the last week roads are empty in central Delhi, you can park wherever you want in Connaught Place and Metro looks like a Disneyland ride. And it all because of Bharat Sarkar's paranoia. Faced with a problem of any kind, trust the Indian Government to apply its default setting response- a lot of men with with a lot of guns. Faced with two major challenges in one week, the government has gone into an overdrive of paranoid schizophrenia turning entire New Delhi into one giant airport terminal where strip search is mandatory. 

Thanks to their efforts, Central Delhi has overnight become this incredibly peaceful town of a couple of thousands where you can see the blue sky and see the birds chirping. As M J Akbar has suggested enjoy an empty Delhi while it lasts, just stay away from the Commonwealth Games or any Hindu organization offices.

Image: Babri Mosque, Ayodhya
Image Credit: Wikimedia